LOLcat - Invisible Bow and ArrowI read an article on The Renegade Writer about the seven differences between being a writing fangirl or a real writer by Linda Formichelli.

The point of her article is that ‘fanfolk’ spend more time acting the part of a writer than actually writing. Real writers on the other hand, write.

Of the seven differences she outlines, number 4 hit a nerve in all the right spots.

Anyone looking at you, with your exclamation point tattoo and “Writer at Work” doorknob hanger, would think you are a writer. But…are you actually writing? Don’t delude yourself: A collection of quill pens does not a writer make. – Linda Formichelli

Note: I don’t have an exclamation point tattoo. If you’re gonna go there, go for an interrabang.

It’s the difference between a person who wears a thousand-dollar tracksuit to sit on the couch and another person who hits the pavement for a five-mile run every morning.

I have a confession.

Without knowing it, I was a creative writing fangirl for years.

I still have the paraphernalia. Blank journals, dozens of pens and pencils, buttons that read “I’m silently correcting your grammar” (even though I don’t); the works. I still have a small army of books about writing that I still haven’t read past the first chapter, mostly because I don’t want to mark up these lovely trappings and make them less shiny.

When it comes to copywriting, I’m in the trenches and doing the work on a daily basis. It’s my job, and I love my job. When I leave the office, I leave knowing that I left it on the field. I’m fortunate that I get to do something I love for a living.

But as much as I love copywriting, it doesn’t count towards my creative writing which I love just as much.

And that’s there where I hang my head in shame.

I’ve spent more time shopping for books on writing that I have reading them. I’ve spent more time obsessing over the word count in my blog posts than racking up my word counts in my WIPs. I have more blank journals than full ones.

Thankfully, I’ve been changing since the universe gave me a much-needed kick in the tail a couple of months ago.

I’ve been working on my primary WIP whenever I can and in doing so, I’ve added more than 3,000 words to it. Now it’s up to 5,054 and will be longer before I go to bed tonight.

I’ve been reading Plot and Structure by James Scott Bell and as I go through it, I’m marking it up with notes and underlines and highlights. (Note: not a paid link.)

For the past two months, I’ve been hitting the writerly pavement; hard.

Now whenever I feel myself slipping, I have a word for that kind of person I don’t want to be. And I owe Linda a world of thanks for giving me that word so I can stay on the right side of the fence.

I don’t want to be a fangirl. I want to be a writer.

When I post a blog post, I try to be helpful and make about it you, not me. But this time I needed to just be honest about my shortcoming.

Learn from my mistakes. Take a few minutes to read Linda’s post. See if anything resonates with you. Here’s the link again: Are You a Writing Fangirl…Or a REAL Writer? 7 Ways to Know by Linda Formichelli

And Linda, if you ever read this: thank you for the extra kick in the tail.

3 responses to “A Writing Fangirl Confession”

  1. Willi Avatar

    Yeah – I think maybe for the pet projects we should schedule time to have a little writing party? Let me know.

  2. Willi Avatar

    Linda is pretty awesome – but you should cut yourself some slack. It’s really easy to be a fangirl when your FT job is writing!!

    1. Erica Avatar

      Thank you! You have an excellent point. Some (most) days when I get home, the last thing I want to do is write. Because I’ve been at it for up to nine hours already.

      Thank you, friend.

Share your thoughts

I’m Erica Wall.

Erica Wall, Rubber Ducky Copywriter

Award-winning copywriter.
Real-world creative writer.
Multi-cup-a-day coffee drinker.

Answers to a cat.

Present and ready to write.

Resolutions for 2026

  • Block off three hours a week to write
  • Delegate more to reduce overwhelm
  • Clean up and clean out home office
  • Practice finishing what I start
  • Practice good habits and let results be whatever they’ll be

“If you don’t have time to read, you don’t have the time (or the tools) to write. Simple as that.”
> Stephen King

“There is nothing to writing. All you do is sit down at a typewriter and bleed.” 
> Ernest Hemingway

“Cut out all these exclamation points. An exclamation point is like laughing at your own joke.” 
F. Scott Fitzgerald

“I love deadlines. I love the whooshing noise they make as they go by.”
> Douglas Adams

“Creativity is intelligence having fun.” 
>Albert Einstein